In the United States, millions of seniors rely on Social Security benefits, but recent reports have raised alarms about the increasing number of overpayments made by the Social Security Administration (SSA). Some of these overpayments are causing severe financial hardship for recipients who now face hefty repayment demands.
One shocking case in 2023 highlights the struggles of a Texas woman who was told by the SSA that she owed over $40,000 — after waiting nearly two and a half years for notification. To make matters worse, the SSA gave her only 30 days to repay the entire amount and stopped paying her benefits completely by the end of 2019. This situation has raised serious concerns about the fairness and accuracy of the SSA’s payment system.
A Nationwide Issue
According to the SSA, improper payments, which mostly include overpayments, are not uncommon. Between fiscal years 2015 and 2022, the agency made approximately $71.8 billion in improper payments. However, this amount only represents 0.84% of the nearly $8.6 trillion in benefits the SSA paid out during that period. Even though overpayments account for a small percentage of total benefits, they can have a significant impact on individuals when they occur.
A December 2023 poll conducted by Redfield & Wilton Strategies for Newsweek found that one in four Social Security recipients had experienced accidental overpayments. The poll also revealed that many recipients were asked to repay these amounts, sometimes under stressful and difficult conditions.
The number of people facing repayment issues is striking. The SSA demands repayment from about 2 million people each year, as uncovered by a Freedom of Information Act request made by KFF Health News and Cox Media Group.
The Financial Struggles of Overpaid Seniors
For many recipients, overpayments create immense financial stress. One case, involved a Missouri man who owed $67,000 to the SSA after receiving overpaid benefits. This unfortunate man lost his car and eventually became homeless. He expressed his sorrow, stating, “I am so sad losing everything at 68 years old. Thank God for food stamps.” Stories like his highlight the extreme consequences of overpayment errors, especially for vulnerable seniors.
New Policies to Prevent Overpayments
To address this growing concern, the SSA introduced new policies in 2024 aimed at reducing the impact of overpayments. Previously, the SSA would withhold 100% of a recipient’s monthly benefits in repayment, but now, they only collect the greater of 10% or $10 from individuals.
Additionally, the maximum repayment term has been extended from 36 months to 60 months, allowing beneficiaries more time to repay. The SSA also made it easier to request a waiver if individuals feel they shouldn’t be required to pay or if they cannot afford to do so. Another significant change is the shifting of the burden of proof. This means that claimants no longer need to prove they were not overpaid; instead, the SSA will need to show evidence that overpayment occurred.
Despite these changes, some seniors are still facing the threat of losing all their benefits. In September 2024, the SSA was still withholding 100% of benefits from about 7,000 people, showing that there’s still much work to be done in ensuring that overpayment policies are fair and transparent.
How to Deal with Overpayments
If you’re told that you owe money due to an overpayment, it’s essential to handle the situation carefully. The SSA will notify you by mail if they believe you’ve been overpaid. If you don’t agree with the amount they’re requesting, you can appeal within 60 days. If you feel you shouldn’t have to repay the overpaid amount, you can submit a “Request for Waiver of Overpayment Recovery.”
For those who owe $1,000 or less, you can request a waiver over the phone, saving time and paperwork. If you don’t take action, the SSA will begin withholding a portion of your future benefits. If you no longer receive benefits, you’ll need to set up a repayment plan with the SSA. Failure to do so could result in the SSA garnishing your tax returns, wages, or future benefits.
Be Proactive: Protect Yourself from Overpayments
For seniors, it’s crucial to stay proactive and keep track of your Social Security benefits to avoid potential overpayments. According to the SSA, nearly 90% of people aged 65 and older receive Social Security benefits, so it’s essential to ensure that your records are accurate. Here are a few steps to help you avoid overpayment issues:
- Check Your Earnings History: Visit my Social Security to review your earnings record and make sure it’s accurate. This will help you spot any discrepancies early.
- Use the Benefit Calculator: The SSA provides a calculator to help estimate how much you should be receiving in benefits. This can be useful to spot any issues with your payments.
- Understand the Rules: If you previously worked in the public sector or received disability benefits, it’s vital to understand how different rules might apply to your situation.
- Report Changes: If you return to work while receiving disability payments or if you have a non-covered pension, be sure to report these changes to the SSA. Not doing so can lead to overpayments.
By staying proactive and informed, you can reduce the likelihood of facing an overpayment situation and avoid unnecessary financial stress.
Conclusion
Social Security overpayments are becoming an increasing concern for seniors across the United States. While the SSA is taking steps to reduce these issues, the responsibility lies with beneficiaries to stay informed and proactive in managing their benefits.
If you believe you’ve been overpaid or are facing repayment requests, it’s important to take action immediately and seek assistance from the SSA to resolve the issue. By understanding the rules and staying on top of your records, you can protect yourself from the financial hardship that overpayments can cause.
Disclaimer: This article has been meticulously fact-checked by our team to ensure accuracy and uphold transparency. We strive to deliver trustworthy and dependable content to our readers.