Former President Donald Trump has reignited his push to overhaul the U.S. tax system, making bold promises to eliminate taxes on various forms of income and spending. While this may sound like a continued effort to honor his campaign promises, many experts and conservative strategists believe these new ideas are unlikely to gain traction with the House GOP.
Conservative economist Brian Reidl shared his skepticism on X (formerly Twitter) on Monday, stating that the likelihood of the House GOP agreeing to Trump’s proposals is virtually nonexistent.
Trump’s Tax Vision
In a speech to House Republicans at his Doral club in South Florida, Trump emphasized his commitment to tax cuts, including those from his 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA). He restated his pledge to eliminate taxes on things like tips, Social Security benefits, and overtime pay, which had been key points of his earlier campaign. Trump’s rhetoric, echoing the promises made during his presidential campaign, seems aimed at energizing his supporters and pushing for further tax reductions.
Richard Rubin, a tax analyst for The Wall Street Journal, reported that Trump’s speech to the House GOP reiterated these promises, with Trump stating, “We’re working very hard to get them done.” This message is clear: Trump wants to expand the scope of tax cuts to include areas beyond just income and corporate tax reductions.
Reidl’s Reality Check
However, not everyone shares Trump’s enthusiasm for these new tax proposals. Brian Reidl, a respected conservative economist and strategist, cast doubt on the possibility of House Republicans supporting Trump’s tax plans. Reidl pointed out that GOP members are primarily focused on making cuts to government spending and ensuring that the current tax cuts under TCJA are extended. In fact, much of the Republican Party’s energy has been directed at reducing the deficit, not increasing it.
Reidl criticized Trump’s suggestions as unrealistic, saying, “I cannot imagine there being much appetite to then blow their deficit numbers back up with this nonsense.” He continued, explaining that in his discussions with members of both the House and Senate, he has not heard any significant interest in the ideas Trump proposed regarding tips, overtime, and Social Security benefits. According to Reidl, the GOP’s focus remains firmly on the TCJA, not on new tax cuts in these areas.
The SALT Controversy
Another key point of contention in Trump’s new tax plan is the State and Local Tax (SALT) deduction. As part of the 2017 tax cuts, Republicans sharply limited the SALT deduction, hoping it would disproportionately affect wealthier individuals in Democratic-controlled states, which tend to have higher taxes. The move was designed to generate more revenue by capping tax deductions for high earners in these states.
'Nonsense': Conservative strategist says House GOP won't entertain Trump's new tax ideas https://t.co/Pw6vO4uukm
— @googeliart.bsky.social 🦋 (@GoogeliArt) January 28, 2025
However, critics argue that the SALT cap disproportionately benefits the wealthy and limits the savings from the tax cuts for those in higher-tax states. This has created a divide within the Republican Party, with some members pushing for a reversal of the SALT cap, while others remain opposed. Trump’s tax ideas, which could potentially expand these cuts, are seen by many as an unnecessary complication that may not deliver the intended relief to those who need it most.
The ‘No Tax on Tips’ Proposal
Trump’s suggestion to eliminate taxes on tips, though politically popular, has also faced backlash. This proposal, which gained attention during the 2020 campaign, was even adopted by former Vice President Kamala Harris in her own campaign. While the idea of relieving workers from paying taxes on tips is appealing, experts warn that its implementation could be a logistical nightmare. Some argue that it may not actually benefit the workers it intends to help, and it could create further complications in the tax system.
In practice, experts suggest that this policy would likely be difficult to enforce and could lead to a mess of unintended consequences. Although the proposal is a crowd-pleaser, especially among those in the service industry, its real-world effects may not align with the intended benefits.
The GOP’s Focus on Fiscal Responsibility
For now, it seems the House GOP is more concerned with maintaining fiscal responsibility than extending tax cuts in the areas Trump is championing. Republicans are largely focused on the extension of the TCJA, which they see as a vital step to reducing taxes for businesses and individuals across the country. However, expanding tax breaks to include things like overtime pay and Social Security benefits, as Trump has suggested, may not align with the party’s broader goals of reducing the deficit and reigning in government spending.
Despite the challenges, Trump’s tax promises could resonate with his supporters, especially those in the working class who stand to benefit from the proposed changes. However, as Reidl pointed out, the reality in Washington is far different from the promises made on the campaign trail.
Conclusion
While Trump’s tax proposals are garnering attention, it seems unlikely that the House GOP will support the new tax cuts on tips, overtime, and Social Security benefits. With Republicans focused on extending the TCJA and reducing the deficit, Trump’s tax plans may face significant opposition within his own party. The debate over the SALT deduction and the practicality of his new proposals will continue to shape the conversation in Washington.